The movie industry long has fought any efforts to impose content-based restrictions, with the courts and the law recognizing and giving wide berth to Hollywood’s First Amendment privileges.
But a surrogate sector of movie making–the billion-dollar adult entertainment industry–almost from its start has borne the brunt of efforts to impose government restrictions, also battling in the highest courts over whether blue laws are reasonable or outright censorship. These movies makers scored a win recently when the U.S. Third Circuit Court of Appeals threw out a lower court decision and ruled in their favor on a case involving performers and film-makers’ need to maintain records about them.
Though proponents of the requirements said they provided a deterrent to exploitation of under-age actors and actresses and a tool to combat child pornography, which isn’t constitutionally protected, opponents said the rules edged into the territory of content controls barred by the First Amendment. (more…)